Torrington Catholics- Latest Religious News
  • Login
  • Home
  • Church
  • Institute
  • Tradition
  • Catholicism
  • Symbols
  • Poetry
  • Stained Glass
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Church
  • Institute
  • Tradition
  • Catholicism
  • Symbols
  • Poetry
  • Stained Glass
No Result
View All Result
Torrington Catholics- Latest Religious News
No Result
View All Result
Home Symbols

I have questions about the NYT’s ‘Saying Goodbye to Hanukkah’

admin by admin
December 13, 2020
in Symbols
0
I have questions about the NYT’s ‘Saying Goodbye to Hanukkah’
0
SHARES
30
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


(December 13, 2020 / JNS) I’ve questions in regards to the New York Occasions’ parenting article, “Saying Goodbye to Hanukkah,” revealed on Dec. 4, 2020.

The piece was written by kids’s e-book writer Sarah Prager, a self-described non-Jewish lady whose Jewish father and Catholic mom raised her Unitarian. All through her life, she has by no means noticed any Jewish holidays. She recounts how she (like the remainder of her prolonged household) has chosen to not proceed her household’s vacation custom of consuming latkes, lighting a menorah on Hanukkah, reciting Hebrew prayers (which, as she explains in her piece, she skilled as meaningless) and adorning their Christmas tree with Jewish symbols. She and her non-Jewish spouse and their two non-Jewish kids, she writes, is not going to be celebrating Hanukkah—solely Christmas and Easter (although in a secular approach), as a result of that’s what her prolonged household celebrates.

I’m curious in regards to the considering that went into publishing that piece. I’m not offended by somebody selecting to not have fun a vacation from my non secular custom. And I’m not offended that the opinion was revealed. I’m a fan of publishing controversial opinions. I simply don’t get it. I need assistance understanding what vital perception about this Jewish vacation, or about giving it up, warranted an article within the venerable New York Occasions.

Given the ideological leanings on the paper, I might virtually perceive the reasoning if the thesis of the piece had been about treating Hanukkah much less as a spiritual observance than a type of what’s now known as cultural or non secular “appropriation” (the adoption of components of a minority’s tradition by members of a extra dominant group). This specific appropriation doesn’t hassle me. So long as it’s completed with a respectful intention, it’s positive with me for non-Jewish folks (whether or not or not they’ve Jewish relations) to make use of Jewish stars on their Christmas timber, eat latkes, mild menorahs and even say Hebrew prayers with out understanding them or discovering them significant. However strictly talking, that’s not a spiritual observance, even when it feels much less “secular” than the opposite methods wherein an individual celebrates the vacations.

Subscribe to The JNS Every day Syndicate
by e-mail and by no means miss
our high tales

Extra to the purpose, it strikes me that if a author had pitched an an identical piece that substituted another non-Christian faith for Judaism, it will have been acquired otherwise by the Occasions’ editors.

Think about, for instance, if the piece had revolved round a non-Hindu lady who was raised Unitarian by her Hindu father and Catholic mom and by no means celebrated any Hindu holidays. As a baby, her household’s vacation traditions included, amongst different issues, consuming vegetable pakoras, lighting the oil lamps utilized in celebrating Diwali and adorning her household’s Christmas tree with photos of Ganesha. Would the Occasions have thought she had the standing to jot down a bit about her selection to not have fun Diwali along with her two non-Hindu kids and her ex-Catholic spouse? And would the paper have revealed such a bit, titling it “Saying Goodbye to Diwali”?

If the reply is sure to each, then, though I nonetheless don’t perceive the considering, I’ve no drawback with the selection to publish “Saying Goodbye to Hanukkah.” I think, nevertheless, that had such an alternate piece been steered, it will have instantly been rejected as absurd. And that’s what issues me. A paper that’s exquisitely delicate to indignities suffered by folks of virtually each non-majority background is oddly insensitive to folks from a selected one.

It’s not that I feel that Jews (or anybody else) must be handled with child gloves. It’s a query of a double commonplace. When the New York Occasions treats Jews with much less sensitivity than it treats members of different minority teams, it sends a message that there’s something about Jews that’s much less deserving of concern and care.

Too simply, this double commonplace can descend towards anti-Semitism—one thing the Occasions can have hassle even recognizing. So I’ve questions.

I hope the paper of report has them, too.

Pamela Paresky, PhD, is a author for “Psychology At the moment,” writer of “A Yr of Kindness” and was the chief researcher and in-house editor for the New York Occasions bestseller, “The Coddling of the American Thoughts.” She serves as Visiting Senior Analysis Affiliate on the College of Chicago’s Stevanovich Institute on the Formation of Data and Senior Scholar on the Community Contagion Analysis Institute, the place she researches extremism and anti-Semitism. Comply with her on Twitter @PamelaParesky.

This text was first revealed by the Jewish Journal.





Source link

admin

admin

Related Posts

Pope Francis strips Vatican Secretariat of State of assets in reform move
Symbols

Pope Francis strips Vatican Secretariat of State of assets in reform move

December 29, 2020
The Trump Administration’s Final Push to Make It Easier for Religious Employers to Discriminate
Symbols

The Trump Administration’s Final Push to Make It Easier for Religious Employers to Discriminate

December 28, 2020
Kathryn Lopez: Christian examples and warnings – Salisbury Post
Symbols

Kathryn Lopez: Christian examples and warnings – Salisbury Post

December 27, 2020
Next Post
Litbits: What’s on in the Canberra literary scene from December 5, 2020 | The Canberra Times

Litbits: What's on in the Canberra literary scene from December 5, 2020 | The Canberra Times

Filipino Dominican priest-scientist works on affordable yeast-based Covid-19 vaccine

Filipino Dominican priest-scientist works on affordable yeast-based Covid-19 vaccine

New Christmas music from Arizona artists: Jordin Sparks, Bogan Via

New Christmas music from Arizona artists: Jordin Sparks, Bogan Via

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow Us

  • 22M Fans
  • 85 Followers
  • 113k Subscribers

Recommended

Dallas Catholics, faith-based agencies pitch in to help migrant teens

Dallas Catholics, faith-based agencies pitch in to help migrant teens

3 weeks ago
Global Catholic Climate Movement: Raise your voice on behalf of our common home

Global Catholic Climate Movement: Raise your voice on behalf of our common home

3 months ago
Trinity Hall taps Georgetown prep principal for new head of school

Trinity Hall taps Georgetown prep principal for new head of school

3 months ago
Review: Thomas Becket at the British Museum

Review: Thomas Becket at the British Museum

6 days ago

Instagram

    Please install/update and activate JNews Instagram plugin.

Categories

  • Catholicism
  • Church
  • Institute
  • Poetry
  • Stained Glass
  • Symbols
  • Tradition

Best Picks

No Result
View All Result

Highlights

St. Luke’s Sacred Heart Campus Opens Advanced Detox Unit

Some things will never change | Commentary

Australian Cardinal Edward Cassidy spearheaded ecumenical, interfaith efforts

Project HOME shows archbishop how it cares for the homeless – Catholic Philly

Hans Küng, Catholic theologian who challenged papal authority, dies at 93

Want to know more about Catholic Social Teaching? Here’s a primer

Trending

New stained glass windows are installed at St. Therese Catholic | Local News
Church

New stained glass windows are installed at St. Therese Catholic | Local News

by admin
April 11, 2021
0

4 new stained glass home windows have been put in within the parish church at St....

‘How many of us will be left?’ Catholic nuns face loss, pain

‘How many of us will be left?’ Catholic nuns face loss, pain

April 11, 2021
Sister Janice McLaughlin, nun who exposed abuses in Rhodesia, dies at 79

Sister Janice McLaughlin, nun who exposed abuses in Rhodesia, dies at 79

April 10, 2021
St. Luke’s Sacred Heart Campus Opens Advanced Detox Unit

St. Luke’s Sacred Heart Campus Opens Advanced Detox Unit

April 10, 2021
Some things will never change | Commentary

Some things will never change | Commentary

April 10, 2021

About

Torrington Catholics- Latest Religious News

For all catholic news feel free to visit and enjoy...!

Recent News

  • New stained glass windows are installed at St. Therese Catholic | Local News
  • ‘How many of us will be left?’ Catholic nuns face loss, pain
  • Sister Janice McLaughlin, nun who exposed abuses in Rhodesia, dies at 79

Category

  • Catholicism
  • Church
  • Institute
  • Poetry
  • Stained Glass
  • Symbols
  • Tradition

Newletter

To stay on top of the ever-changing world of Crypto, subscribe now to our newsletters.

Loading

*We hate spam as you do.

 

  • Privacy Policy
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright © 2020 Torrington Catholics. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Church
  • Institute
  • Tradition
  • Catholicism
  • Symbols
  • Poetry
  • Stained Glass

Copyright © 2020 Torrington Catholics. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In